I was very flattered to be asked to judge the new Cannes Grey Lions award this week and be the keynote speaker at their launch event. Quite apart from a cheeky trip to Dublin there were many reasons I thought this was a great thing to be involved with.
To put it into context here are some numbers I dug up for my talk:
9 – the average age of agency employees
2% of the advertising workforce is over 50
????% of creatives over 50
25 – average age of creative teams
52 – average age of car buyers
70% of all disposable income is controlled by Baby Boomers
78% of over 50s feel underrepresented or misrepresented in adverts
The fact that only 6.2% of advertising employees are over 50 is evidence that older people are not valued in Adland. That’s 6.2% across all the departments. So, the percentage of creatives over 50 is tiny. Older creatives are underappreciated and often side-lined. Many of them freelance and I know from the comments I get from members of my ‘Society of Very Senior Creatives’ that getting work when you’re over 50 is really tough – even if you’ve got a shed full of awards already.
But this award is different.
The Cannes Grey Lion is not a lifetime achievement award. It’s not a pat on the back award for people who’ve already got a tonne of awards under their belt, or a well done for being a Creative Director award. It’s an award for great creatives who may have been overlooked for a very long time. It’s an award for people who have had to take a career break and are making a comeback in their 50s. It’s an award for people who may have only just got into advertising in their 50s. Because, as is evidenced by recent research: many people don’t reach their creative peak until they’re over 50!
Here’s why I think the new Cannes Grey Lion initiative by IAPI is a great idea.
It will raise awareness
That this award has been recognised by the Cannes Lions committee is testament to the fact that Adland is finally waking up to the lack of elder creatives in the industry. It may not be the solution but it is definitely a step in the right direction. And by raising awareness I hope it will make a difference.
Interestingly the people who are already aware of this problem are the millennials and Gen Z. For them diversity is the norm and they are more likely to notice the lack of it. So, it’s not really surprising that the idea for this award came from a Young Lion.
It will stamp on stereotypes
Adland is going through huge changes at the moment and the traditional model no longer exists. This has resulted in a lot of ‘traditional’ or ‘older’ creatives losing their jobs. That’s because the perception of anyone over 50 is that they don’t understand digital culture, they’re out of touch and they’re expensive. There is also the opinion that if you’re a creative in your 50s and you haven’t been made Creative Director or won a load of awards by now you’re probably not very good.
I am hoping this award will challenge these assumptions. It’s a chance for ‘Very Senior Creatives’ to show off their stripes. To silence the doubters and stick two fingers up at our ridiculously youth-oriented business. Because not everyone wants to be a Creative Director. Some people just love making ads.
It will encourage creative comebacks
The truth is if you’re over 50 and still working as a creative in Adland you may well have been coasting for the last 15 years. Keeping a low profile and just getting on with your job while life takes priority over work. Often these people are very good creatives. They produce the work that is needed but they don’t chase fame and glory, they don’t want to work on pitches and they don’t go to social occasions and networking events that could progress their careers.
There are many reasons people take their foot off the career pedal in their 30s and 40s. Maybe it’s to look after kids, or elderly parents, or ailing partners, or even themselves. Advertising can be a very stressful industry and I know several people who just had to take time out for their sanity.
Creative parents often find they can’t put in the ridiculous hours expected of them at work and help their kids with their homework, take them to a different afterschool activity every day and cook dinner for the family. But that doesn’t make them bad creatives.
Other creatives may have just not got the break they always wanted. Working for clients and brands that wouldn’t take risks, or working in a sector where awards are few and far between.
One of the main problems with the lack of creatives over 50 in the industry is that there are no role models and no mentors. There’s no one to advise younger creatives on how to manage their career progression, how to juggle life and work, how to ask for a pay-rise, how to freelance etc. So instead of looking forward to being a ‘Very Senior Creative’ younger creatives are scared of getting to that stage.
The other really big problem is that young creatives are less likely to put older people in their ads. When they do they are often the stereotypes of doddery, lonely old people with no life and certainly no fashion sense – unless they are extreme like Baddie Winkle or Iris Apfel.
It will inspire change
The best way to change people’s opinions is to prove them wrong. To demonstrate that what they thought was the truth is a lie. To make them do a double take, to show them another way, to actually do it. Giving women’s football equal prominence in the media this year changed a lot of minds. And celebrating Paralympic athletes as Superhumans transformed how we see disabled people. In the same way, I hope that awarding older creatives will change the way bosses and recruiters see them.
I got my first job in an agency when I was 31. I know other people who started in their 40s and I know others who are thinking of switching careers in their 50s. In our ‘100-year life‘ being 50 is only half way there. So, we don’t just need to keep the older creatives we’ve already got, we need to recruit more.
This award will be controversial but I think it is important. Now we are all living longer and it’s unlikely that we will retire by 65, we need to recognise and celebrate the benefits that being over 50 brings.
If this encourages more people in their 50s to step up and reignite or revive their careers then it has to be a good thing.
If it makes people think about where all the older creatives have gone that’s a good thing.
And if it encourages more agencies and recruiters to rethink their attitudes to their current employees and the ones they’re thinking of hiring then that’s got to be a good thing too.
The only bad thing about this award really is the name. I think it immediately puts people off and as several senior creatives rightly pointed out many people in their 50s are not grey. I’m currently purple.