AML has CMOs for dinner (again)

The latest in AML’s roundtables for CMOs was at the wonderful Luca restaurant. Ian Henderson, AML Chair, started by asking how CMOs balance the demands of creativity and accountability in an increasingly complicated world.

At AML’s last roundtable in New York, one CMO likened their job to lifting a barbell. At one end sit creativity, judgement and the nerve to ask an awkward question. At the other sit data, automation and AI. Both ends are getting heavier. And somehow you’re meant to lift the whole thing faster than you did last quarter.

We took that simple idea as the starting point for our latest edition in London. Over a lively and highly engaged evening (with superb food and wine, of course – thanks Luca) the barbell gave a way into a much wider discussion. It also prompted an immediate objection: a barbell is supposed to be in balance. In marketing, it rarely is.

Start with what customers value

Nobody chooses a brand because its marketing team has a beautifully integrated tech stack. They might choose it because it makes something difficult feel straightforward, or because they trust someone will pick up the phone when it matters. The technology can help deliver both – but it’s rarely the reason people come back.

So the table was enthusiastically on the human side of the barbell, not out of nostalgia, but because origination and critical thinking are what take brands beyond the competent, predictable – and forgettable. (Gartner’s data* offers a counterintuitive twist that supports the human end. Despite the assumption that AI would cut people costs, labour is actually taking a larger share of marketing budgets, not a smaller one.)

Being found isn’t the same as being believed

There’s a genuine tension between quantity and quality. One guest fretted that a single really good article might be overlooked by the algorithms, while another regretted producing around 30 white papers a month that nobody read. That led to a discussion of what the table called ‘measureship’; counting what’s easy to count, mistaking it for true leadership which is harder to quantify**.

But being found and being believed are different. Make your work easy to find, then give people a reason to remember who wrote it. That usually means returning to a clear point of view, not finding twelve more ways to say what everyone else is saying. A simple, relevant, unifying creative idea.

One way out is to look beyond your own category. Your customers probably don’t need another account of the trends they spend all week dealing with. They might welcome an idea from another field that helps them see a familiar problem differently. The test is whether you’re bringing them something they couldn’t have got from the next speaker at their own industry conference.

Stand out for the right reason

Marketers are taught to prize difference. Buyers don’t always see it that way. Sometimes they want a challenger that does things differently. Sometimes they want a choice they can explain to their boss without a slide deck. It helps to know which decision they’re making before you start writing the brief.

The barbell is also reshaping how CMOs build teams and choose partners. Several guests felt that expecting one agency to excel at both ends of the bar is unrealistic and that agencies trying to do so risk contorting themselves into shapes that make no sense. A more realistic model pairs partners who will genuinely challenge on brand and creativity with specialist technology, data and enablement partners on the other end.

Commercial models are shifting too. If AI can review a contract in seconds, time-based billing comes under pressure, for law firms and agencies alike. Clients, especially private equity backed ones, are moving towards payment by results on hard commercial metrics. The best agencies are willing to accept that.

What this means for CMOs

A few clear principles emerged from the evening:

  • Sell belief, not volume. In a world of AI, the brands that win will be the ones people believe. Consistency builds authority. Output counts do not.
  • Resist measureship. Do not let what is easiest to measure decide what gets made or funded.
  • Borrow relevance. Apply your genuine expertise to other sectors’ problems rather than repeating what your clients already know about their own.
  • Test your assumptions about perception. Know how your brand is really seen in each market before making decisions on its behalf.
  • Pick your field, or your herd. Sometimes the right move is uncontested space. Sometimes it is being the most credible option in a familiar field.
  • Protect the core. Do not trade the audience that defines you, for growth elsewhere.
  • Invest in human capability. Critical thinking, challenge and originality need to be trained deliberately, especially for the next generation.

The barbell will keep getting heavier. The CMOs who lift it well will be those who use the machine end to create space for the human end, not to replace it. AML would like to thank the CMOs who contributed to this and previous conversations. And we’re already looking forward to the next one.